Showing posts with label traditional degree. Show all posts
Showing posts with label traditional degree. Show all posts

Saturday, 18 February 2012

Guest blog post by language grad, Marie

Visit Marie's blog at
Grad and Looking


Today's post has been written by Marie, a French and Cultural Studies graduate whose career goal is to work in advertising. She writes spiritedly about the intense competition faced by those of us chasing our dreams in this popular industry, and highlights the main challenges and, even more helpfully, how we can face them.

Her story, of how she was inspired to carry out an internship in China in order to get that little bit closer to her dream job, emphasises just how much of a challenge today's job market can be. As she rightly points out, an internship abroad is not a viable option for all of us, but it just goes to show how important it is to make the most of the opportunities we are presented with. And, as I pointed out in my TARGETjobs blog post last week, the extra hurdles that we have to jump will just make us that much stronger candidates than if we had only to walk to the finish line.


Graduated and looking…

Hey everyone! My name’s Marie and like Jos (and many of you reading this) I am trying to break into the increasingly difficult marcoms industry – more specifically advertising.  A recent French and Cultural Studies graduate from the University of Sussex I know that there are two main things that advertising agencies think twice about when I apply:

1) I don’t come from a business/marketing/advertising background
2) My lack of agency experience (particularly because when I was first applying for grad schemes this time last year, I’d only had a couple of weeks of experience at an independent B2B agency in London)

So what to do you when any one of those two things are held against you? Well determination and pro-activeness play a huge part.  During my final year last year I applied for virtually nearly every advertising grad scheme that was out there that appealed to me, from AMV BBDO, to Iris, to Ogilvy, balancing uni deadlines with application deadlines, which always seemed to coincide. Unfortunately, despite all the hard work, out of the fifteen or so applications I sent I only received one invitation to interview (and as you can see from this blog entry, I didn’t get through to that agency’s assessment day that year). What had I done wrong? I had worked so hard and spent so much time on every single application. Couldn’t they see my extreme passion for the industry and eagerness to learn? I knew that my lack of experience was my main hindrance and that I needed to go out and get some, but I also knew that if I didn’t focus on the one important matter of gaining a good degree, my chances of working within the industry could be taken away from me completely. So for the last few months of my degree, I knuckled down and the hard work of a 4-year course finally paid off! But as graduation approached, reality dawned on me. Whenever bumping into relatives and family friends the same old questions and exclamations kept resurfacing, “What will you do now you’ve finished?”, “What, you haven’t got a job!?”, “There are lots of sales and recruitment roles out there, why don’t you pursue those options instead?”, “How about teaching? Lots of language students go into teaching…”.  The questions were never-ending, and whilst annoying, I knew that they all had my best interest at heart. But I didn’t want to go into sales, or recruitment, or teaching despite the constant competition and rejection I knew I was putting myself up for. There were simply industries that I wasn’t passionate about.  As the questions kept flooding in I started to do some research and finally found my solution: I was going to do an internship… in Shanghai.

Yes, that’s right Shanghai, China. I took the extreme option of moving halfway across the world for several months in order for me to get some of that integral work experience under my belt. And what an experience it was! It was undoubtedly worth every single penny that I had scrimped and saved up for during the summer at my part-time job. But why China of all places? Well three reasons really. Firstly, I’ve always had a soft spot for China, having grown up in Hong Kong until the age of 11, and I knew that I always wanted to go back. Secondly, being a language geek, I knew sometime after uni I wanted to start learning Mandarin, so what better excuse than to go and learn the language whilst being immersed by it! And finally, and maybe most importantly, the fact that China is an emerging market, that has not only become the second largest global ad market but that it is expected to surpass the UK and become the biggest consumer market in the next 10-15 years. As a result of this huge expansion, I know that employers, no matter what industry you want to go into, will start to look for potential employees who have had experience and understand the subtle differences between China and the West. It was easy for me. I didn’t need much persuading as I have never been one to be afraid of a challenge, particularly one that involved travelling and living abroad, having already spent a year living in France in my 3rd year.

So last October, after 4 months of saving, I said goodbye to my family and friends, got on a plane and joined 30 other interns from around the world to take part in a two-month internship organised by CRCC Asia Ltd. I was working as a marketing and events intern for a small independent local advertising agency whose main channel is a website dedicated to helping expats moving to and living in Shanghai (I wont go into great detail about my internship but if you want to know more about what I did there feel free to visit my blog www.gradandlooking.blogspot.com). Whilst it wasn’t specifically an advertising internship that I had initially asked for when applying for the programme, I threw myself into it and as I was working for an SME, I learnt an extensive amount about event marketing, event management and social media marketing, and was given a huge amount of responsibility from negotiating with sponsors to devising and planning the agency’s biggest event of the year! I also learnt about Chinese business culture, including the importance of networking and guan’xi, and keeping ones face (mian’xi) and more importantly I learnt so much about myself as a person. Despite the never-ending cultural shocks that I faced in a city that is in a continuous state of change and growth, I never felt lost.  Even though frustration became a frequent sentiment in my day-to-day life as a graduate on my very own journey to the East, I learnt and improved upon many skills that were unbeknown to me! Whether it was my acting abilities during my first weekend when trying to look for coat hangers and struggling to find the word in my phrasebook (I am proud to say that I am pretty good at charades now!), or my ability in hiding my true feelings towards some unknown Chinese delicacy that I had to eat out of politeness (there were many dishes whose ingredients were unrecognisable, and perhaps to my relief will continue to remain unknown), or successfully holding my own on the metro and reaching my desired metro stop without being shoved and pushed off the stop before, Shanghai showed me that I can adapt to any unfamiliar situation.

Now I’m back in the UK, my life in Shanghai seems like a blur and I miss China terribly – I know it’s a place I would love to return to in the future to live and work. So what am I doing now? Well unfortunately I missed out on the majority of advertising grad schemes whilst away, but I have managed to apply for the few schemes whose deadlines were after Christmas and consequently been invited to interviews and an assessment day. I am also applying to entry-level advertising account executive job vacancies that I have seen, but surprisingly I have seen that even with me having several months of experience, for most vacancies this isn’t enough – they want at least a year’s worth! We just can’t win. For that reason I feel that grad schemes are so important to aspiring ad execs like myself, and that more companies should have them, or at least have a few trainee vacancies as many of us cannot afford to work for free for a year, especially with our student debt looming above us! Without a doubt my two-months of overseas experience have been integral to the success of my grad scheme applications this year, and I now have so much more to talk about during those important competency based questions that we are all so familiar with! However despite the fact that there is a high possibility that I may have to undertake some more work experience whilst working part time, I do not regret any part of my expensive decision to go abroad. I am not saying that you all have to go to the same extreme lengths that I have (after all going all the way to China might not appeal to everyone’s tastes and pockets), but that the key to getting noticed in the marcoms industry is to definitely get as much work experience as you can whether it’s an independent local agency or one in the big cities like London, Manchester, Birmingham etc. It really annoys me when I see headlines and reports stating how lazy our generation are. If they call people who are working for free for months on end just to get a foot on the career ladder in order to start paying off our scarily high debts lazy, I don’t know what more they expect from us. We all just have to keep at it and maintain our sense of humour. Be determined, be pro-active, be patient, and hopefully someone somewhere will see how much we want that ever-important first job. Good luck to you all J!

Marie xox

(If you have any questions or comments please don’t hesitate to contact me by following me on Twitter @mklw20 or connecting with me on LinkedIn).

Sunday, 15 January 2012

Being an academic grad in today's graduate job market

If you managed to read my guest blog post for the blog of fellow non-marketing grad Michael Palmer - who smashed down the potential barrier of his History MA to get a great position as an SEO consultant - thank you very much!

I wanted to keep that post brief, but if you've been brought here from Michael's blog, I guess you might be interested in reading more about being an academic graduate struggling to get the vocation you want in today's job market. So I might take this opportunity to have a bit more of a rant about the whole thing.

What does a degree in a traditional subject count for nowadays?

What I talk about in my guest post on Michael's blog - about the recent change in the job market that has apparently led to an aversion towards recruiting traditional subject candidates - is affecting thousands of graduates, who have worked hard in embarking on what they had believed to be the best possible start to building a career.

This change needs to be talked about, as the many graduates referred to in the press, who are out of work or unable to obtain decent job roles, are victims of it - left floundering in the wake of those who opted for more vocational subjects. As I have said in my guest blog post, it is not my place to comment on which of these types of graduates make better candidates for jobs. However, I’d like to try and offer some support for grads facing the frustration of feeling like all the hard work you have put in to getting your degree is not appreciated, if only by letting you know that you’re not alone. In order to do this, I think it’s important to start by documenting how the world had seemed to us as wee 17 year olds filling out our UCAS forms in 2007.

Why pick a traditional subject?

Everyone had had it imprinted on their grey matter throughout their childhood that a degree was the strongest path to take in order to be successful, and our small-world perspectives meant that we felt wholely unable to go against the advice that Oxbridge and the Russell Group were the crème de la crème, and where you should be aiming to attend if you wanted to make your degree a worthwhile investment of a great deal of money, time and effort.

I know you wanted to know just how a leech walks


Having slogged away for three years in an incredibly pressurised and competitive learning environment, immersing myself in topics that were incredibly fascinating but also widely irrelevant to most jobs (for example, how leeches walk), it makes this trend, of hiring based on a strict criteria that rejects non-marketing grads, all the more bitter a pill to swallow.

Last February, the Guardian reported that Oxbridge and redbrick institutions had confirmed that they hold a higher regard for A-levels in more theoretical ‘hard’subjects, such as English, Maths, Science, Geography, History and languages, stating that by choosing more recently-established A-level subjects such as Media and Business, students appeared to be ‘avoiding a challenge’. Many of us could have guessed that this attitude is commonplace amongst these elite unis, owing to the fact that they are known as ‘leading’ universities because they are long-established, and so are specialists in the older and more traditional subjects. Moreover, a lot of them don’t tend to even teach courses outside of traditional academia. 
Take for instance this quote off of the Oxford website: 

Business Studies
Oxford University does not offer an undergraduate degree in this subject, though there are opportunities to study it as a graduate course. 
However, if you are interested in a career in Business, then any course at Oxford can be an excellent preparation. 

I think this is a pretty apt summation of what has long been the established attitude (that is now threatened) to undergraduate study – that a degree, particularly one acquired at one of the top academic institutions in both the country and the world, is enough to develop you into a candidate competent enough to tackle a job role in the outside world.

Applying to jobs with an academic degree

I understand that many companies do not have the resources to train up grads; it is much quicker and easier to hire someone who has studied the subject. As I’ve said, I'm not here to comment on whether marketing grads are 'better' than non-marketing grads - this obviously varies from person to person, and also depending on the job role in question - but my problem is the droves of job roles that will only consider a graduate who has studied marketing/related. 

Peruse any job site and you will find “must have studied a marketing or business degree” or similar in a large proportion of job descriptions. I pulled this example off the Guardian Jobs website. They are asking for a ‘Marketing Assistant/Graduate’:

This famous leisure brand is seeking a confident Marketing Assistant to make a significant contribution towards their marketing activities. Candidates will be degree educated and will have obtained at least a 2:1 within a business or marketing related subject! Candidates will only be considered if they are recent graduates of 2011 or due to be finishing within 2012.

Key aspects of this fantastic role will be liaising with external client enquiries, keeping the website up-to-date, producing marketing brochure materials, analysing customer satisfaction data and assisting with the management of corporate events. The organisation in question is seeking someone with some commercial flair, someone who can adapt quickly and use their communication skills to heighten company awareness.

I’m very sure that most, if not all, of those duties could be carried out by any competent graduate. Having worked in a project management role with a focus on marketing, which seems quite similar to what they are asking here, this would be a role I would feel quite comfortable in. Employers are certainly spoilt for choice nowadays, but it’s just no help to us if we’re forbidden to even apply.

They are looking for someone who can “use their communication skills to heighten company awareness” – implying these communication skills need to come from a degree. But why discount those who may have developed communication skills from work experience? Experience that meant them applying their skills to a real-life situation which may have even brought about measurable success for a company. Job descriptions like these are no good for us graduates in traditional subjects, and their prevalence is both disheartening and concerning.

This attitude to recruitment spans not only job roles in SMEs, but graduate schemes too! (For example: Wilkinson's Brand Development and Digital Marketing programmes.) And having worked on graduate recruitment campaigns for large international clients, I can tell you that there is a definite favouritism towards marketing-related degrees over demonstrable interest and competency in the field via other endeavours, despite the fact these schemes are supposed to be training programmes.

Phew, I needed to get all of that out of my system!

Of course, there are lots of things you can do if you’re a graduate embarking on the road to a great career, even if, like me, you find yourself having to combat the obstacle of your academic degree. I just felt like I needed to make a frank acknowledgement of the problems faced by graduates of academic subjects before I got round to actually addressing them :)

If you are in the same situation as me and have any comments or experiences you want to share, please feel free to comment, or contact me if you are interested in writing a guest blog post! Follow me on Twitter @JosCanavan or connect with me on Linkedin.